Reflection on EEND676Y - Collab Web Tools in Education
Well here it is the beginning of April and I have finished my 2nd class in this cohort. Looking back over the last 8 weeks, it has really gone by quickly, I realize that I have explored so many great tools and even tried some in my classroom that will enhance my students collaboration. The possibilities are endless. One of the first projects we were assigned was to explore and evaluate online collaboration tools. We had to make a rubric that we would use to evaluate the 2 tools that we wanted explore and learn more about. I looked at several tools and the 2 I decided to write about were Padlet and Kahoot. Kahoot I have used in my classroom and Padlet I have not, but I'm looking forward to the possibilities. I'm uploading the paper that I wrote for these 2 collaboration tools and the rubric I used to evaluate them.
Artifact #1
Collaborative Web
Tools
The two web tools that I evaluated were Padlet and
Kahoot. There are so many collaborative
web tools to use and so many of them are more advanced for my
kindergartners. I tried to find web
tools that I would use in my classroom or have used in my classroom. My rubric
looked at the effectiveness, privacy, user-friendliness, grade level, and
cost.
First I will discuss the web tool, Padlet. Padlet is a great way for teachers and
students to collaborate. It’s like a big
bulletin board that you can place a post it on.
The post it can contain a picture, a video, drawing, a website, or a
note. There are a lot of possibilities in which to use Padlet. It can be used to learn about your classroom,
formative assessments, collaborative research, and for students to share things
they are working on. In kindergarten, I
have thought about how to use Padlet and since I have found out that they have
added a video portion to it, I will be using this like I used Filpgrid. The ease of use is better in Padlet than in
Flipgrid. An example of how I will use this tool would be during our community
helper unit. Students would be
researching different jobs in collaborative groups and deciding what job they
would like to have and why. They would
use Padlet to then video themselves with the job they would like and why they
want to do that job. The class can then watch the other students and what they
had to say about the job and what they have learned. As far as the scoring of the rubric for
Padlet I would score the following way: effectiveness -3, user-friendly – 2,
privacy – 2, grade level – 3, cost – 3.
The reason for a 2 on user-friendly would be because I have kindergarten
and I will need to show them at least once how to use the program, but after
that they should be able to handle it themselves. The 2 on the privacy because they can use my
information, but students information isn’t shared, they don’t need to sign in
with email address or name.
The next web tool I have used in my classroom is
Kahoot. Kahoot is a student response
tool using a game based learning platform.
Teachers can create quizzes, or use some that have already been
made. Students can even create their own
quizzes. It’s great for formative
assessments as well as getting the class to collaborate. Last year I used Kahoot to get my kids into
groups and take a quiz. I would read the
question and they would then collaborate on which answer their group thought
was correct. It really got them talking
and giving their reasons for what they thought was right and wrong. There are other ways to use Kahoot, like for
homework. I have not explored this
option much, one because I have kindergartners, and two, they may not have the
resources to have Kahoot available to them at home. Therefore, I would only use this in the
classroom. The scoring on the rubric for
Kahoot would be: effectiveness – 3, user-friendly -2, privacy – 3, grade-level
– 2, cost – 3. The reason for 2 under
user friendly is I would have to show them how to use this website and it may
take a couple of times for them to get the hang of it. The 2 for grade level is because not all of
this website is applicable for kindergarten.
The homework portion of it is difficult for kindergarten and because of
the lack of resources that the families have.
Not every student may have access to the website at home.
These are 2 tools that I have used or will use in my
classroom based on what I have scored them on the rubric and knowing that they
can be used effectively in my classroom. Kahoot seems to get the classroom
collaborating in groups more than Padlet does, at least for my intended
purposes at this point. The
collaboration that would take place with Padlet would be done while the
research is being done. Once the
research is done, that is when we would use Padlet. I feel that they are both good collaboration
tools, but Kahoot is a little more collaborative while the tool is being used. Padlet
will be easier to use for my students, there aren’t as many steps involved for
them to get their job done. Kahoot seems to be a bit more private than Padlet. With Padlet there is a possibility of information
getting on the internet but that’s only if it were to be shared. However, students information like name,
email address or address is not available.
The cost for what I’d be using the tools for are both free so that’s a
huge plus. They are both suitable for my
grade level, however I feel there is more on Kahoot for grades higher than
kindergarten, like the homework portion and the students being able to make
their own quizzes.
3
|
2
|
1
|
|
Effectiveness
|
The program has strong connection to the purpose and appropriate for
student.
|
The program has limited connection to the purpose and somewhat
appropriate for student.
|
The program does not connect to the purpose and is not appropriate
for the student.
|
User-Friendly
|
Students can open and operate the program independently.
|
Students need to have the teacher model how to operate the program.
|
Students need to be showed how to use program each time it’s used.
|
Privacy
|
Collects no personal student information/any info. Collected can’t be
displayed publicly.
|
Personal info is displayed publicly. Info is not sold or shared to a
3rd party.
|
Personal info is displayed and can be shared and sold to 3rd parties.
Student info is used in unrelated ways.
|
Grade-level
|
All features suitable and appropriate for grade level.
|
Majority of features suitable for intended grade level.
|
Not suitable for intended grade level.
|
Cost
|
Free or special low price for educational users for abundant
features.
|
Average cost for features offered.
|
High cost relative to features.
|
Artifact #2
My second artifact was also part of my first class artifacts. I did a little tweaking to the project here and there and I think I made it much better. I made a project where we would be discussing the letters of the alphabet and their sounds. The students were to come up with words that began with each letter of the alphabet. We then were going to discuss words that began with each letter and that we could also find in the school. Each group had certain letters to work with and come up with the words for those letters. After they decided on a word we would go on a scavenger hunt through the school to find the word and take a picture of it. Each group was then responsible for making a Google slide with their picture and a caption for their slide. This was pretty much the same for the last time I made the assignment, however this time I needed to assess them and make a rubric for what I was looking for. I also made a Google Form quiz for them to take using the pictures from the You can see from the first class and my artifacts the way to get into my Google Classroom. I will upload the rubric and quiz that I made to enhance this assignment.
Collaborative Task Rubric
Collaborative Tasks
|
Novice (1)
|
Emerging (2)
|
Proficient (3)
|
Exceptional (4)
|
Contributes
Information
|
Never
|
Occasionally
|
Usually
|
All of the time
|
Responsible/
Completes all Tasks
|
Never participates/
Completes task
|
Occasionally participates/
Completes partial task
|
Usually participates/
Completes most of task
|
Participates all of the time/
Completes entire task..
|
Listens to group
members
|
Never listens to group members
|
Listens to group members sometimes.
|
Listens to group members most of the time.
|
Listens to group members all of the time.
|
Takes turns/
Cooperates
|
Argues with the group often.
|
Will sometimes argue with the group.
|
Argues with the group on occasion
|
Never argues with the group and works out any problems.
|
Makes fair decisions
|
Always wants things their way.
|
Considerate to others in the group occasionally.
|
Considerate to others and their views
most of the time
|
Always considerate to the group and their points of view and guides
the group in decision making.
|
Content (knowledge of
letters and their sounds.)
|
Information is incorrect and shows little understanding of content.
|
Some solid information was presented.
|
Information was clear and correct throughout most of the
presentation.
|
Information was well presented, clear, and correct.
|
Graphics
|
Images do not connect to the text and are not relevant.
|
Images are not always relevant to the text.
|
Images are mostly relevant to the text.
|
Images are relevantand complement the text.
|
Use of Class TIme
|
Did not use classtime to focus on project. Was distracted by others
and reminders were given.
|
Used some of classtime to focus on project, Some trouble staying
focused. Distracted by others.
|
Used time well during class.
Usually focused on project. Not
distracted by others.
|
Used time will during class.
Focus was on the project. Not
distracted by others.
|
Having to create these rubrics really stops to make you think about many things. Is this aligned to my curriculum? Am I assessing the proper things? What is it that I really want to assess? Will the grading make it fair to everyone? The rubric will take the guesswork out of my grading. I will know which column each student will be in and add up the points and there I have it. I'm done with grading. If I didn't have the rubrics I would be guessing at things and every student may not get graded the same way. There is more consistency throughout the class and their grades which makes me feel much better.
So as I finish this class I can say that I have not only learned a lot about collaboration tools and how to use them in my class, but I've also learned a great deal about grading and rubrics and how to create them. Online collaboration is a great tool. I have found ways to incorporate it in kindergarten and I know that as the students get older they will have even more opportunities to collaborate with other schools, other places, and possibly even other countries. The possibilities are endless for our students. It's an exciting thought and I hope that more and more districts and educators will allow these opportunities to happen for our students. It's the age of technology. It won't be going away, it will only expand and we have to try and keep our students up to date with technology and with the endless possibilities for them.
No comments:
Post a Comment